Even Good Parents Can Raise a Juvee - Not every apple falling from the tree is ripe.
“One of the oldest fundamental liberty interests consistently recognized by the Supreme Court is the interest of parents in the care, custody, and control of their children.” Justice Wiggins
This week the theme is “Was justice done?” Depending on who you ask justice has a different meaning. Even the same person will change their definition in a different situation; it can take on an entirely different meaning. Some people define justice from a moral or religious standpoint while others from a common sense standpoint and still others define it along the lines of trying to run a city or town or the State of Iowa. Many people define justice as the courts interpreting the law to support whatever it is they want to do having no regard for the rights of others. So how do you define justice?
Let’s begin today with a recent ruling from the Iowa Supreme Court having to do with the City of Davenport ordinance that attempts to punish parents when their children act as juvenile deliquents. The ordinance made the parent criminally liable when the child violated the law.
In this case before the Iowa Supreme Court the court struck down as unconstitutional the City of Davenport’s parental responsibility ordinance. One of several interesting aspects of the case is the dissent by Ternus and Cady choosing deference to the Iowa legislature rather than to allow the Courts through this ruling to protect the rights of its citizens through the Constitutional mechanism. One has to wonder whether the removal campaign is having an influence.
Continue Reading